An Honest Review of Grain Belt from August Schell Brewing Co.

Ok, if you read this blog there is a good chance you are either a beer geek or a beer snob. Either way, American Lagers really don’t seem to sit well with either crowd. Geeks do seem a bit more forgiving seeing as snobs usually only like specific beers, styles, or big beers. Geeks tend to, for the most part, accept beers for what they are. Since the American lager, American Light Lager, and American Premium Lager (all to most people seem the same, and really they are quite close) for the most part don’t offer up the complex malt, yeast, or hop flavors and aromas the truest of beer lovers seek out. So generally these beers sit on the shelf waiting for Mr. Busch Light fan to make the step out of the box, or the wannabe beer geek who wants something that looks dangerous but really just offers him or her the comfort of a Budweiser. But in my opinion, even the American lager styles have their place. Here I am going to review August Schell Brewing Co against the Premium American Lager category. Addition: The reason I am putting “An Honest Review” of Grain Belt, is because after finishing my review I started reading others reviews of the same beer and it seems that there are many people who automatically hated this beer even before trying it. Again, it’s that beer snobbery that “American lagers suck because they don’t have tons of malt and/or hops” type of attitude that I feel a true beer lover needs to try to overcome. I admit, I was one of those guys myself early in my discovery of good beer. But judging in competition gave me a new appreciation of how hard those styles can be to produce just right.

First I want to comment on the bottle, a clear bottle is not a good thing for a beer (Miller Genuine Draft aside with their modified hops). I am just glad I bought this in a 12 pack that was in a fully enclosed box. But off the pour the beer is a nice light gold and crystal clear. There is a lot of carbonation and the beer appears very effervescent. There is a stiff mousey head that is very white. As the beer sat, the head remained as a solid 1/8″ cap on the beer. That’s quite impressive.(3)

The aroma actually has some spicy hop flair. There is some sweet  malt as well as some corn in the nose. What is most impressive is that the hop character is in no way hidden. It is quite evident right off the first sniff. There may be some low lying levels of DMS, but I’ll be honest and say that to me it’s more corn character than that canned corn aroma you get from DMS.  I am quite impressed so far.(10)

The flavor is a touch sweet and corny. Very easy drinking with a nice spicy hop flavor through the middle with a soft and subtle bitter finish that fades quickly. Although the carbonation in the beer offers a crisp feel while drinking, that part fades quickly with the sweetness. The sweetness lingers quite a while and to me is obviously from corn as an adjunct (which is OK per style). The style guidelines state that this beer should be even, and it is. A great balance between malt and hops, I just wish it would finish a bit dryer.(12)

The mouthfeel is medium and carbonation is high, as it should be per style. There is no astringency and overall very nice. (4)

Ok, overall for what this beer is, it is excellent.  The sweetness is just slightly off-putting, but all in all this is a very easy drinking summer beer I can live with. I can honestly say that I will buy this beer again and possibly stock it for my family that drinks what they call “Light Beer”. It may not be my personal flavor of choice, but the obvious hop presence and malt flavor makes this beer a winning choice for my go to American Lager without a doubt. (8)

I give it  a 37 which to me can be either a B+ or A- depending on mood.

Review of Bell’s Oktoberfest

This is the final Oktoberfest review I have for this fall. I know I originally had six, but I took one with me to a brewfest and simply drank it, which reminds me I forgot to do a blog post on that fest.
The aroma is rich in bready and sweet malts along with some piney hops. The aroma of this beer was OK, but just a bit off style. Although on a personal note, I enjoy the hop aroma, this is not appropriate for a traditional Oktoberfest style. (7)

The beer poured a nice clear orange color with a dense frothy head. The clarity was good and overall looks great for an Oktoberfest. (3)

The overall the flavor is a bit weak and very basic. There should be a distinct complex maltyness that I feel is not here in this beer. What malt I do get is an unmistakable biscuit flavor. There is very little sweetness and a  slight caramel flavor which is not right. There should be toffee if anything and I get more along the lines of caramel than toffee.  The beer does finish dry. Bitterness is low with a lingering bitterness that hangs in the back. Overall, not that complex. (12)

Mouthfeel is medium and creamy. Carbonation is good, and there is no astringency. (5)

Overall the beer is good, but is just too much of some qualities per the style, and lacking overall complexity and depth that you see in a world class Oktoberfest. The caramel notes along with the American hop aroma is not right for the style, but does make for a good drinking beer. With a bit more malt complexity, and swapping out the caramel notes for more of a toffee note would do the beer some justice. All in all I enjoyed drinking this beer quite a bit, but for an Oktoberfest it fell a bit short. So I am having conflicting feelings about the overall score. (6)

Overall I give this beer a 33, but would be willing to bump it up a notch or two. On my personal scale a 33 is about  a B- or C+. But don’t get me wrong, this beer is very good, just not great or world class.

Review of Capital Brewery’s Special Pilsner

Capital Special Pils

Capital Special Pils

Today I am reviewing Capital Brewery’s Special Pilsner. This beer is a German Pilsner, so we can expect a dry and crisp bitter German lager with some noble hop aroma. Capital is a Wisconsin brewery that can be found in Wisconsin, Illinois, Minnesota, and Michigan so unless  you live in these states, you may have to make Capital one of your Wisconsin brewery’s to pick up, for the most part they have some great beers.

You will notice that I will be putting numbers behind each segment of the review. This is what number I would be giving each segment if I was judging this in a BJCP competition. Just keep in mind that these numbers are mine alone based simply upon my own take on the style. Generally in competition you have at least one other judge at the table and you have to come to a consensus on the beer. So there may be another judge who didn’t see things this way and we would have to debate the beer in order to come to an agreement. So in other words, my numbers are just my palates interpretation of the style and what I am drinking.

The aroma is very light, with a touch of sweetness in the malt profile. There is some DMS in the aroma, which is sort of like canned corn. This aroma is very light and is acceptable for this style because of the use of Pils malt. Unfortunately, I am not getting much for hop aroma. I get a light aroma, but not what I am expecting for a German Pils. The hop aroma I do get is mildly spicy. (8)

The color is light yellow and quite clear. There was not much in the way of head and what was there disappeared very quickly. (1)

I like the flavor of this German Pils. There is a crisp biscuit flavor in the malt profile along with a subtle sweetness. The beer’s hop profile is spot on in the flavor realm I think. There is a bitterness that grabs you in the middle and pulls you through into the finish. There is some spiciness right up front that fades to simply bitterness. The hop flavor lasts quite a while in pleasant way. There is no over the top hop bitterness that you want to wash away, but rather a soft lingering presence that lets you know you just drank some German hops, and it doesn’t want you to forget.(17)

The carbonation is very high, as it should be in this beer. The mouthfeel is a bit light for the style though, just a bit watery.(3)

Overall a great beer. I feel this is a great example of the style, but could use a bit more hop aroma. The mouthfeel was a bit lacking as well. But all the components are there and the flavor was just outstanding in my eyes. This one is a keeper. (9)

So in the end I would give this beer a 38, based on the weaker aroma, lighter mouthfeel, and I would like to have just a touch more malt in the beer. Not much more malt, just a little bit. That may also help with the mouthfeel as well. A 38 in my eyes is a B-, which is still excellent.

New Glarus Hard Hat Brewery Tour/Review of Unplugged Cran-bic Ale

Welcome to New Glarus, you will never want to leave.

Welcome to New Glarus, you will never want to leave.

Yesterday I was lucky enough to attend the New Glarus Hard Hat Brewery tour. This tour is $18.50 and only held at 1pm on Friday afternoons. Now at first glance the price may seem a bit steep for a brewery tour, but this tour is well worth the price and lasted from 1pm until 4pm. You start out your tour, which is limited to 15 people, at New Glarus’s first location. You tour the small brewery and get a good look at the processes and bottling lines here. We got in to the fermentation area and had a great Q & A session with a guy there who specializes in fermentation processes. From here, we move on to the new Hilltop Brewery and get an all access pass in that brewery. There is a self guided tour at this brewery as well that is free, but the advantage of the Hard Hat tour is you have three tour guides, and gain access to areas that are closed off and roped off to regular visitors. We also had a meet and greet with Dan Carey, the owner and head brewmaster of New Glarus. Upon completion of the tour, you are led upstairs for an exclusive tasting of select New Glarus beers including unplugged and R & D beers. Our selections included all beers I have had before, except for Golden Ale, a beer that is only sold from the brewery and you cannot get in stores anywhere. We also had the Coffee Stout which is not going to be released until January, Old English Porter, Cracked Wheat, Raspberry tart, Yokel, and one other one I can’t remember off hand. I got a lot of great information off the tour, and some of it I will share with you guys and gals in this posting. I don’t want to share it all, that way you have more to look forward to when you take the tour. Some of what I heard is great news and some is what I consider very sad news.

Me with Dan Carey (Owner and Head Brewmaster of New Glarus)

Me with Dan Carey (Owner and Head Brewmaster of New Glarus)

The Fermentation Tanks at the old brewery.

The Fermentation Tanks at the old brewery.

There is enough Stainless Steel piping in the new facility to cross Lake Michigan!

There is enough Stainless Steel piping in the new facility to cross Lake Michigan!

One thing that is very evident from our tour, New Glarus treats its employees with great love and respect, and it shows in the employee’s attitude about not only the brewery, but also about their bosses, Deb and Dan Carey. I don’t think I have ever seen this level of love and respect for ones boss ever. It truly reflects the atmosphere of the workplace as a whole. This just shows that quality ingredients, along with quality people and honest love of ones job really creates a high quality product. Our tour was led by Scott, DJ, and Chase and these three really made the tour quite entertaining as well as informative. They made it clear that the tour was for us, the fans and consumers of their beer and without customers like us, New Glarus wouldn’t be what it is today.

One other thing to note is that New Glarus does not have a huge corporation mentality, not only are their brewing processes truly green in that they recycle their waste hot water to heat other processes, but also donate their spent grains to local farmers for livestock food. Yes, donate, not sell. The appearance of the new facility was also designed to not only compliment the local architecture, but also hide any “factory” look the brewery may have. The big red barn on the south side for example, is strictly for aesthetic purposes and hides some unsightly equipment. There is even a beautiful cut stone stairway up to the brewery with a flowing stream as well as flowers, trees, and shrubs. You don’t really feel like you are walking into a stale brewery, but rather a brewing haven.

Some interesting findings I got from the tour, is that New Glarus has no plans to distribute outside of Wisconsin (Sorry rest of the country), even with the ability to brew more with the new brewery. The reason is that even with the increased capacity, they still can only satisfy demand here in Wisconsin. And the demand shows, New Glarus does not distribute outside of Wisconsin, and they are ranked 14th in the US for overall craft beer sales. If you ask me, that is incredible.

I asked Dan Carey about the plans for 2010 as far as the unplugged series plans go. He stated that in 2010 we will see the return of Enigma, Apple Ale, a Belgian (I think he said Belgian quad again, but I am not 100% sure I am remembering correctly), a bock, and some more barrel aged beers. I asked if we will see the return of either Smoke on the porter or maybe another smoked beer, like a smoked IPA. He said the possibility is there in the future, but we will not see anything like that in 2010. He did say that he loved smoked wheat beers, so I personally would like to see a smoked wheat in 2011. So lets keep our fingers crossed. I am fairly excited to see some of the older Unplugged beers repeated for two reasons. First, they were great beers. Second, I saved several of them and if they repeat the beers I can compare young and aged side by side. Off the top of my head I still have a few bottles of Bourbon Barrel Bock and Belgian Quad in the beer cellar so I hope those get repeated.

One bit of sad news I learned yesterday is that Hop Hearty IPA will probably be retired in 2010, and in its place will be a new IPA more along the lines of the west coast IPA’s. For some, this may be a welcome change, but for me it is not. What I love most about Hop hearty is that it is not an American IPA like all others. The malt profile of New Glarus’s IPA has some serious depth and makes them a refreshing change from the overly hopped versions that everyone else has. In the end, I think they will brew a great beer, but I wish it was an addition to the line up instead of killing off an old friend. For me, the Hop Hearty IPA was set apart because of its rich malty profile, combined with the American hops. It was a lot more balanced and offered a lot more complexity than many of the other IPA’s out there. For me, this was an old stand-by if I was in the mood for an IPA that was not like any of the others. I am just happy I have one more year with it.

All in all the tour was a wealth of information about New Glarus and I highly suggest taking the hard hat tour. But if $18.50 does not sit well with you, the self guided tour is free. Another advantage of heading off to New Glarus is being able to by an R&D beer that you will not ever find in stores (but I will be reviewing the Golden Ale soon so stay tuned for that), plus I picked up the Cran-bic Ale which is not supposed to hit stores until November. You can buy it at the brewery, and as a matter of fact, the tour guides told us that they just labeled all those unplugged beers the day before our tour! Talk about fresh.

Another thing to quickly note is that Randy Theil, formerly of Ommegang Brewery now works for New Glarus. Randy was the first American inducted into the Belgian Brewers Guild. So I think we can expect to see some more Belgian influenced creations in the future.

Randy Theil, formerly of Ommegang and the First American inducted into the Belgian Brewers Guild now works for New Glarus.

Randy Theil, formerly of Ommegang and the First American inducted into the Belgian Brewers Guild now works for New Glarus.

Here are a few more photos from the tour.

They were Brewing Spotted Cow at the Hilltop brewery when we arrived

They were Brewing Spotted Cow at the Hilltop brewery when we arrived

Some new kegs full of Snowshoe Red Ale getting ready for shipment in November.

Some new kegs full of Snowshoe Red Ale getting ready for shipment in November.

Our tour guides: Chase, DJ, and Scott. A great group of guys who obviously love their job.

Our tour guides: Chase, DJ, and Scott. A great group of guys who obviously love their job.

The stairway leading up to the tasting room.

The stairway leading up to the tasting room.

We sampled several beers including the Golden Ale, Coffee Stout, and Old English Porter to name a few.

We sampled several beers including the Golden Ale, Coffee Stout, and Old English Porter to name a few.

The advantage of making it to the brewery is you get some beers you cant get elsewhere. They just labeled the Cran-bic ale the day before our tour and I picked up 2 packs. The Golden Ale is only sold at the brewery, you will not find this in stores.

The advantage of making it to the brewery is you get some beers you can't get elsewhere. They just labeled the Cran-bic ale the day before our tour and I picked up 2 packs. The Golden Ale is only sold at the brewery, you will not find this in stores.

Drinking a pint of Fat Squirrel right from the source. I enjoyed this pint on the steps of my favorite brewery, and just soaked in its aura. It was awesome.

Drinking a pint of Fat Squirrel right from the source. I enjoyed this pint on the steps of my favorite brewery, and just soaked in its aura. It was awesome.

Review of New Glarus Cran-Bic Ale

Because I was lucky enough to pick up a few packs of the Cran-Bic Ale, I thought I would do a quick informal review.  It will be interesting to see how this ages because I got this the day it hit the brewery’s store. Cran-Bic Ale is a fruit lambic style beer.

New Glarus Unplugged Cran-Bic Ale

The aroma gives off some very mild earthy and barnyard aroma, lighter than I would have thought with the lambic base, but there. For me, the brett is nice and subtle at this point. I wonder how it will progress. What I got most in the aroma was sweet tart fruit (obviously from the cranberry) along with some clean malt. You will not find any hop aroma here, not only wouldn’t you expect it in a lambic style, but you wouldn’t want it in this beer anyway. ( 10 points)

The color is amazingly red, crystal clear, with a pinkish bubbly head to it. Reminds me of cherry 7up. (3 points)

The flavor is a bit sweet, there is some sourness that mingles well with the tart cranberry. For how red this beer was, I was expecting it to be overwhelmingly cranberry like, just like the Belgian Red is very strong in cherry and Raspberry tart is smash you in the face with it’s raspberry flavor, this beer was not quite as fruit flavor packed as those two. The flavor is very good, with just barely enough brett in it for those who want to find it to be able to, but not nearly enough to put off others. My wife even liked it, and she hates geueze because of the brett character. All in all I didn’t find the cranberry flavor all that much as you have come to expect from cranberry juice, but was rather more like semi-tart cherry than dry and puckering like I expected. The lambic side of this beer is tart, acidic, and only slightly funkdafied, which will appeal to the masses. The sweetness is just enough to offset the tart slightly, and also plays with the fruit. As a good fruit lambic should, the fruit takes center stage but the lambic side is noticable. Great beer! (18 points)

Mouthfeel is light, and there is enough body from the malt and fruit to prevent this beer from feeling too watery. The beer is tart, but not astringent. (4 points)

In the end, this will be a huge hit during the holidays, because it is just enough lambic to keep the beer geeks interested, and enough fruit beer to satisfy those looking for an easy drinking, sweet, and refreshing holiday beer. But if you are a hardcore geueze or lambic fan, don’t expect to be hit over the head with funk, I think this beer was meant to be more a sweet holiday alternative to the traditional holiday spiced beers. For me, I would like to see just a touch more lambic quality to the beer, but that will come forward with age. I personally wouldn’t change a thing at this point. (9 points)

Final score is 44 points! That is a solid A in my book and I am more than happy to lay that score on this beer.

Total Brew In A Bag, 1st attempt

Today I brewed an IPA using a whopping 10 ounces of palisade, simcoe, amarillo, and homegrown glacier hops. This beer also used 15.5 lbs of grain, including 2 row base malt, Victory, Vienna, and crystal malt. For the whole recipe, see the bottom of the post.

I have brewed many beers in my day, and most of them have been all grain, but this brew session was a bit different. I decided to to try out the brew in a bag method. This is where you use all your water, do not sparge, and all your grains are contained within a bag. Then instead of sparging, you just remove the grains and bag from the kettle and continue on with the rest of your brewing process. One thing I discovered is that a 5 gallon paint strainer bag is not big enough for a keggle. For next time I will have to use a custom made bag.

I had a very difficult time finding an accurate temperature. I was getting reading varying from 148 in the center of the mash, to 160 in the outer portions. I attribute this to having a bag too small for the process. The good news is I did get conversion, the wort was sweet. I realized that my hydrometer broke during the last brew session, so I gave a sample to my friend and he is supposed to email me the OG. I’ll see what my OG was sometime tonight (it turned out to be 1.059). Other than that, the process was very slick and I will be trying it again with a bigger custom made bag.

The second full bag method I employed was using a hop sack. Since I was using 10oz of hops, I wanted to be able to pull them out o fthe kettle making it easier to transfer with less hops to strain out.

Above are the hops, below is the way I hung the strainer as to not have it resting on the bottom. The bag was weighed down with two stainless steel nuts.

Here are the grains pulled from the kettle, my brewing friend Brian is holding the bag.

As you can see the bag is a bit small. Below is the hops pulled, and this is also a 5 gallon bag. It does appear I got a lot of hop character even through the bag because the bedroom where my bucket is fermenting in, smells very thick of hops. I like it, but my wife is not overly thrilled.

Any good brewing session is not complete without some good beers.

So, when all is said and done I don’t think my first brew in a bag session was a success. I don’t think the bag’s size allowed for a true representation of the method. So my main reason for posting this blog entry was to prove that even when many many batches under your belt, picking up a new technique can lead to mistakes. But as long as you learn from them and either adjust the new technique to fit your system. or drop it all together and stay with what works, at least you are trying to improve or simplify the process, which is progress. Before I end up tweaking the recipe, I will first get this process down. I really like the way this recipe looks, and contains some of my favorite IPA components: Simcoe and Amarillo Hops with Victory and Vienna Malts.

D.O.A. IPA

11.00 lb      Brewers Malt 2-Row (Briess) (1.8 SRM)
2.00 lb       Victory Malt (biscuit) (Briess) (28.0 SRM)
1.50 lb       Vienna Malt (Briess) (3.5 SRM)
1.00 lb       Caramel/Crystal Malt – 40L (40.0 SRM)
0.50 oz       Newport [9.30 %]  (60 min)
0.50 oz       Newport [9.30 %]  (40 min)
1.00 oz       Simcoe [11.90 %]  (25 min)
1.00 oz       Amarillo Gold [8.60 %]  (20 min)
1.00 oz       Palisade [6.30 %]  (20 min)
1.00 oz       Simcoe [11.90 %]  (15 min)
1.00 oz       Palisade [6.30 %]  (15 min)
1.00 oz       Amarillo Gold [8.60 %]  (10 min)
1.00 oz       Palisade [6.30 %]  (5 min)
1.00 oz       Glacier [4.50 %]  (5 min)
1.00 oz       Glacier [4.50 %]  (0 min)     -
1.00 items    Whirlfloc Tablet (Boil 15.0 min)
2 Pkgs        SafAle American Ale (DCL #US-05)

9.6 gallons of water total heated to 160 to hit a mash temp of 154. (I did have a hard time hitting the proper temp with the small bag)

90 minute mash

Heated pot to 180 for mash out, removed and drained grains.

Boil=60 minutes

Ended up with 5.25 gallons total.

Review of Summit Oktoberfest

Here is another beer in this installment of the Oktoberfest beers. This is Summit Oktoberfest.

The beer pours a nice amber color with about an inch layer of dense head on top the beer (See Picture). The beer has good clarity

The aroma is a bit off for a traditional Oktoberfest. To me, there is a lot of caramel in the nose. There is some toasty and bready qualities to the malt nose, but I get sweet caramel, which there shouldn’t be in this style. There is nothing in the way of hops, but I do get some noticable alcohol aroma.  From a strictly beer standpoint, and not stylistically speaking, I really like the aroma of this beer. It’s rich, complex, and quite inviting.

The flavor is very nice. There is some complex malty flavors here. I get some toffee and caramel, quite a bit of toast, and some nice hop flavor that suggests American varieties of hops. I could be wrong, but it tastes that way to me. Just a touch citrusy. The bitterness is right on point and just enough to balance. I do want to mention that there is alcohol in the flavor as well, so this beer is probably above the 5.7% threshold for the style. The beer does start off a touch sweet, but it finishes semi-sweet. There is a bit more sweetness than one would want in the style but for me it works. Again, from a style standpoint the beer misses the mark just a bit. But, for a fine beer and one I am really enjoying, I give it props. The complexity of the grain bill, the interesting hop character, and the slight alcohol bite all contribute to the overall enjoyment of experiencing this beer.

Overall, I would give the beer a C+ for style (a 26 for me on a BJCP scoresheet), there was just too much missing the traditional style. But I’ll give this beer two scores today, one for just overall enjoyability….if that is a word. I give this beer a good solid B+ for that. It is an interesting beer, brewed well, and just plain hits the spot tonight. Sometimes, a brewer can call a beer whatever he wants, and even if it misses that style’s mark, that doesn’t change the fact that it’s a damn fine beer.